hi,this thread might take us up to the 16th june.ok then witch rivers would you rather fish out of the above post,and why.
derek.
| Author | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
blinkerman |
fishing clear rivers or coloured rivers. |
Lead | |
|
hi,this thread might take us up to the 16th june.ok then witch rivers would you rather fish out of the above post,and why.
|
|||
simon irvine |
|||
|
I prefer a coloured river as i think the fish feed better and more confidently also in winter it usually means we`ve had a bit of rain so the water temp is
usually up a bit. The fish find it harder to see those giant feeders i fire into the river although after watching the the new barbel dvd i think the will
still be able to make them out !
CHEERS SI |
|||
Mark Partridge |
|||
|
Hi Derek,
Have fished all types and by far prefer fishing coloured rivers (that is without the leg-up of being able to see the fish) as it's so much more of a challenge. In fact I'd say the most pleasure available in barbel fishing is to be had from using watercraft and bait knowledge alone to winkle one or two out of a swollen lower Severn or Trent. HTH Mark. |
|||
Bullhead bill |
|||
|
hmmmmmm........intresting Thread Derek, what do you prefer and why
?
|
|||
New Temer |
|||
|
Where's mine just gone ????????????
Edit : sorry looking at the wrong one
8ft of flood water on lovely atb ian
Last Edited By: New Temer
04/06/08 21:08.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
sneakypeter |
|||
|
Derek, I much prefer the challenge of coloured, or big waters, you have to work hard for consistant results, and its always a buzz catching unseen fish, you
just never know what takes your bait, big or small. I enjoy the different challenge of small clear rivers too, working out the right way to fool a seen fish,
both types have there appeal, but catching unseen monsters is what really floats my boat.
peter |
|||
scubasteve |
|||
|
Give me a coloured river any day.
There is something special about having to do the hard work of finding the fish by using time/experience/watercraft/elimination/etc and that sudden donk on the rod top as you nail another one.................. The adrenaline rush is awesome. I feel that it is lost a bit when you can see the fish coming and you know its picked up the bait. Yes, its all very nice seeing fish, and even on that ditch some call the Severn, its possible to see Barbel, but its the not knowing that is the exciting bit for me. I think the problem is that many do one or the other, so you have nothing but your own prejudices and preconceptions to judge each against. Like Mark, having done both I know which I would choose....... Give me 10ft of extra Welsh water any time. Steve |
|||
hatterbarbel |
|||
|
Hi men , Easy , easy one this . Id rather catch 1 fish all day stalking , lowering in bait , and getting " done " , making subtle changes to rigs / feeding , before watching it pick it up !!!, than catching a few in mucky waters . I know what Steve is on about though , working out where they should be , and sometimes in conditions that others are watching from a warm dry front room .
But no , for me and Sue , tap water please . Hatter |
|||
scubasteve |
|||
|
But Mark, that's exactly what I'm on about.
You have come to that decision having done both types. I have to admit, I'm enjoying my small river/clear water fishing (well I will be in a about 11 days) but I can see what's happening, so its easy Be good to catch up with yourself and Sue on the Teme this summer mate............. Steve |
|||
hatterbarbel |
|||
|
Hi men ,
agreed with you there Steve . Will catch up , the fox pub is calling .
best catch up with you there , as Luton wont catch the Wolves up , another 10 points deducted today , so blue square here we come.
Hatter |
|||
Angie Iamarat |
|||
|
I prefer a coloured one too, its more challenging. My ex-boyfriend and my dad used to say the same thing too. Mark partridge I agree with you coloured is best.
Angie |
|||
Gaskes |
|||
|
Don't really have much choice in the matter as the rivers I fish are rather murky and where the river slackens the sediment/furry bits are roughly barbel
coloured.
The only time I have seen fish is when they are flashing or jumping out of the water. |
|||
Amil Raj |
|||
|
Hi Angie.............
|
|||
Ian Grant |
|||
|
I'm happy fishing either, i just alter my approach accordingly.
All the best Ian. |
|||
blinkerman |
|||
|
hi,blimy ian that was a quick post. derek.
|
|||
the shepherd |
|||
|
clear water everytime,stalking gives me a buzz.Have caught Thames fish to 9lb which is great but being able to find and target specific fish on my local Avon is awseome |
|||
dougalz |
|||
|
Fish Both of course. Living between Teme, Wye, W.Avon and Severn has got to be the best local mix up of barbel rivers that this country can offer. And Derek I
bet the Warks Avon does an 18 before the Hampy A
Lets all face it - we are all biased and base this on waters we are presently dreaming about. Which is a lovely little trait of the angler. Especially with just 10 days of waiting left, after the 3 month break, we have all had time to dream up where we will go and what we will do and what we will use and how we will dress and when we'll get there and..... Of course for a huge proportion the fishing will be a bit iffy as it always is. Did manage a wye ten on't 16th 2 years back mind |
|||
blinkerman |
|||
|
hi,i never used to always fish for barbel all the time when i lived in hitchin,apart from the petrol money and a 300 mile trip to the avon i was ltd to when i
could go then.i fished the middle ouse in them days mainly after chub [yes in coloured water]i also fished great barford power station after the big carp that
congrigated there in the winter.and i had a amazing story to tell my folks when i arrived home.[well next morning,they where asleep]so what i am trying to say
is i did a lot of travelling to fish my favourite river.
couloured rivers-well here is one thing in your favour,they wont be able to spot you so easally as in a clear river,provided you havnt spooked them by dumping your tackle down on the bank ect.ok,lets say i lived near the river trent,a big,big river where you cant see anything with boats going up and down.its the start of the season,so if it was me i would spend the first few days just looking[no not for fish]but snags,trees if its got any,sidestreams, slower pace water than the main current,even an angler catching one making a note of where he caught it,hearsay from the tackleshop,where two different currents meet,weirpools thats a dead cert,i had one from the thames at penton hook once,and many other areas i havnt mentioned.oh yes and sometimes food gets thrown in the river by boaters,moving and moored up. clear rivers-i would just like to say that a few of you dont seem to know what a difference there is between spotting fish and sight fishing.firstly spotting fish[in my case its either barbel or big chub] i only need to spot 1barbel which will tell me where they are,as there will normally be others around,so that is where i will fish for the rest of the day,with enough cover to hide me from the fish.so i am fishing for any barbel or big chub,plus the rig i use does not catch me any small fish,and there is no special bait either. sight fishing is spotting a very big fish perhaps in a shoul of barbel or even a loner,if a smaller barbel or chub get to the bait first the rig is tweaked to spook them, so waiting until the bigger fish comes back into the swim. i know a lot of you dont believe what cagey barbel do,and this is one of the pleasures of being able to watch them,pick up a bait and drop it before you even strike,and ive said it before, the master at hitting this type of behaviour is terry lampard. if you cant see them then you wont know whats happening to your bait in coloured water.its not happening all the time,but i can assure you it does happen. just one other thing about the avon,as i have said before the river is not always gin clear and if it rains or the riverboard is weed cutting then the river will colour up,and like a lot of you i wont be able to see them either,so you do need to have knowledge of your river and where they will be,or where they have been caught before. of course i might be talking a lot of rubbish,but if one of you take notice then it will be aresult for me. derek the blinkerman. |
|||
jeeves33 |
|||
|
For me..... to see that piece of carbon wrench round ,and for those brief seconds .........when you don,t know if it,s 2 or 20lb...is what it,s all about ! if i have allready seen the fish this part is lost. I have often "passed "on fish i can see, prefering to go where there is still that unknown element,so in answer to the original question i prefer a coloured river. |
|||
blinkerman |
|||
|
hi,mr jeeves you have read that post wrong,if ime walking along the riverbank spotting fish,i said if i only see one barbel that only tells me if there are
barbel there which is what i want,but maybe not the one i want to catch as there will be others bigger in the area,ime sure that a 7lb or 8lb barbel wont be
the biggest in that area,and with bait going in would also bring in others.
derek. |
|||
paulmatty |
|||
|
Hi all,
I love fishing for Barbel whatever the conditions ! But I will say that you will learn more about Barbel in one day on a low, clear river than you will in a season on a coloured river ! The above said, I do love the challenge of a big river in flood ! Diversity is what our sport is all about ! I love to do them all ! Big, Small, Coloured, Clear...........But if I had to choose conditions/river to catch, if my lie depended on it, I' take a coloured Severn with a good steady flood on it ! Cheers Paul M..... |
|||